Log in  |  Register   Fri, July 30, 2010
74° F  |  Traffic

This makes no sense

New realignment idea ‘ridiculous’

By Ron Borges
Friday, March 12, 2010 -
+ Recent Articles
EmailE-mail   PrintablePrint   Comments(15) Comments   LargerSmallerText size  Bookmark and Share Share  

FORT MYERS - Tim Wakefield has seen a lot of baseball in the 16 years and six days he’s spent in the big leagues, but even he can find himself baffled at times by the things that go on. Yesterday morning was such a day.

Sitting at his locker at City of Palms Park preparing to do his daily USA Today crossword puzzle, Wakefield was told of a discussion now going on among members of a 14-person special committee for on-field matters appointed by Commissioner Bud Selig. According to Tom Verducci, the venerable Sports Illustrated baseball writer, one thing the committee is considering to improve competitive balance is to knock everything out of balance. As problem solving ideas go, it seems more addled than adroit.

+ Return to full article
Comments (15)
Sort:
 
cheezball
  ?   0 Good Comment -2 Poor Comment

i think baseball sucks anyways but it is really bad when we have to play jays, rays and zerO's 19 times a year
 
Posted 5 months ago  Reply  Link Abusive
whitelightning
  ?   +2 Good Comment 0 Poor Comment

First thing the dh would have to be made permanent throughout all of baseball to make this fair or stricken from all of baseball permanently.
 
Posted 5 months ago  Reply  Link Abusive
Sorry, but the post that was in this spot has been removed as it did not follow our guidelines.
 
#1242747 - Mar 12, 2010 8:27 AM EST

mosox
  ?   +2 Good Comment 0 Poor Comment

so when a team from the royals, pirates, reds,brewers, nationals division gets spanked in the first round of the playoffs, that creates competative balance?
 
Posted 5 months ago  Reply  Link Abusive
mixjuan
  ?   +1 Good Comment 0 Poor Comment

That is one of the worst ideas I have heard of in a professional setting. How do you mess with tradition?
If they want to creat more parity, they need to start putting a salary floor (with penalty for spending too little) with their salary tax threshold. Start getting teams more in the middle of the spending spectrum to put more competition out there for good players.
 
Posted 5 months ago  Reply  Link Abusive
billleefan
  ?   +2 Good Comment 0 Poor Comment

The proposal benefits the weaker team that moves out of the division (e.g., AL East), penalizes the team that moves in, and does nothing to change the dominance of the strong teams (Sox & NYY). Move one of the strong teams? that breaks up a good intra-divisional rivalry and more or less guarantees that both will make the playoffs.
The present system is more equitable: both strong teams must compete against each other, and some times one knocks the other out (2008, NYY; 2006, Sox). The third team has a shot. The 4th- and 5th-place teams are not likely to benefit significantly simply by being moved.
It's hard to see this proposal working as intended.
 
Posted 5 months ago  Reply  Link Abusive
fuzznutz
  ?   +2 Good Comment 0 Poor Comment

You want more parity? How about a salary cap with that requires a team to spend up to a certain amount, but it also has to force a team to spend up to a minimum amount as well. If you can't afford to spend on a team, maybe you shouldn't own that franchise in the first place.
 
Posted 5 months ago  Reply  Link Abusive
teazer9986
  ?   +2 Good Comment 0 Poor Comment

Are these guys taking cues from the NHL. Whats next a home run hitting contest to decide games.
 
Posted 5 months ago  Reply  Link Abusive
mixjuan replying to teazer9986
  ?   0 Good Comment 0 Poor Comment

HAHAHAHAHA!!! That would be absolutely classic.

side note... I actually miss 0-0 ties in Hockey. those were some of the best games I have ever been able to see. Defenses stepping up and goalies standing on their heads. You walk away with a point and a great deal of respect for the other team
 
Posted 5 months ago  Reply  Link Abusive
teazer9986 replying to mixjuan
  ?   0 Good Comment 0 Poor Comment

Had season tix for Bruins for many years, we kept them for the last year of the old building and the first year of the new...after that it was a "why bother going" feeling that took over me and my buddy. I will watch thursday night and if they don't DO SOMETHING after last week then I am truly gone forever from this team.
 
Posted 5 months ago  Reply  Link Abusive
« Previous  1 2  Next »

Join the BostonHerald.com community

Registration will help us improve the quality of our comments by keeping them on subject and in accordance with our guidelines.

To activate your account, simply complete the short form below and BostonHerald.com will send you a confirmation link to your e-mail.

Only fields marked with asterisk ( * ) are required.

Your Comments: * 
E-mail (must be real)   * 
Username   *  No spaces or special characters please
Password   *  Your password will be case sensitive
Re-enter Password   *   
Gender MaleFemale  
Year of birth  
Zip code  
PLEASE NOTE: If you would like your comments printed in the Opinion section of the newspaper, please provide your full name, location, and telephone number for verification
Full Name:
Phone: - -  
City/State: ,  
  or Sign-In  
rborges@bostonherald.com
JUST IN TIME: Victor Martinez beats...
Photo by AP
JUST IN TIME: Victor Martinez beats the throw to Mets catcher Chris Coste to score on a Jeremy Hermida hit during the Sox’ 8-2 win yesterday in Port St. Lucie, Fla.

Related Articles

Victor Martinez recalls deadline pressure

Victor Martinez recalls deadline pressure Sitting beside his locker before Wednesday’s game at Angel Stadium brought...

Red Sox activate Victor Martinez

ANAHEIM, Calif. - Catcher Victor Martinez was activated from the disabled list on...

Recap: Mariners 5, Red Sox 1

Recap: Mariners 5, Red Sox 1 THE BIG PICTURE SEATTLE -- Each time Jon Lester pitches, the Red Sox expect to win....

More on:

 + Victor Martinez  + Tim Wakefield  + Tom Verducci
Advertisement



Contact us  |   Print advertising  |   Online advertising  |   Herald history  |   News tips  |   Electronic edition  |   Browser upgrade  |   Home delivery  |   Herald wireless

$ave on Boston Herald Home Delivery

Jobs with Herald Media

For back copy information and more information on other collectible copies please call 617-426-3000 Ext. 7714.  Click here for Celtics, Patriots and Red Sox back copies

N.I.E. Smart Edition Mass Literacy Foundation